Meet fellow Club members and enjoy underwater photography together!

Find answers, ask questions, and help each other
to take better underwater photos.

The Underwater Club Forums Equipment and Techniques How Far is Too Far. Editing limits for "Natural History" competitons? Reply To: How Far is Too Far. Editing limits for "Natural History" competitons?

  • Nicolas

    Administrator
    2025-09-29 at 6:28 pm

    Here’s an interesting resource I remembered of – Ocean Art judges feedback, which they provide each year:

    https://www.uwphotographyguide.com/ocean-art/judges

    I know this ins’t a Natural History contest but this is interesting read nonetheless. One of the regular judges – Tony Wu – went on the judge WPY last year and brought his own perspective/preferences there.

    One thing to be aware of we – UW photographers – tend to share an understanding of what a great shot is, which topside shooters/judges may not share. For wide-angle, your classic megafauna photographed up-close with a fisheye lens (distortion creating that ‘in your face’ look), with bright saturated colours, and a sunball behind, are widely regarded (by UW shooters) as the money shot. However, a topside shooter may not appreciate that sort of imagery at all. Renee Capozzola once told me her stunning turtles & sunball shots either did very well in some contests and fell early in others, where she learnt the beautiful sunball felt a little bit “too much” for some jurors.

    This is a useful discussion for anyone looking to enter competitions, and I’d be curious to see how others approach their editing for natural history contests. We’ve got a number of multi award-winning photographers amongst TUC members (yourself included Gabriel), I’ll just tag a few of them to see if they’re willing to chip in (anyone else welcome to comment/complement too!):

    @travellermike @jacobguymedia @Bill @yazid @catherine @jennystock @grace_underwater